De 21 liedjes waaruit het album bestaat, zijn de volgende:
Hier is een lijstje met de liedjes die Olivia Rodrigo & Matt Cornett zou kunnen beslissen om te zingen, ook het album waaruit elk liedje afkomstig is, wordt weergegeven:
- We're All in This Together
- Out of the Old by Olivia Rodrigo
- The Medley, The Mashup
- Role of a Lifetime by Kate Reinders
- When There Was Me And You by Joshua Bassett
- Just For a Moment by Olivia Rodrigo & Joshua Bassett
- Truth, Justice and Songs in Our Key
- All I Want
- Wondering
- I Think I Kinda, You Know
- Born to Be Brave
- Get'cha Head in the Game
- Bop to the Top
- A Billion Sorrys
- Wondering by Olivia Rodrigo & Julia Lester
- Start of Something New
- Out of the Old
- Breaking Free
- Role of a Lifetime
- Just for a Moment
- Stick to the Status Quo